Citation
Detail: Andrew
T. Smith and J. Marc Foggin. 1996. The Plateau
Pika Is A Keystone Species For Biodiversity On The Tibetan Plateau. in: Conserving
China's Biodiversity
(II) (PETER Johan Schei, WANG Sung and XIE Yan eds.).
China Environmental Science Press. Beijing. 211-221p.
The Plateau Pika Is A Keystone Species For Biodiversity On The Tibetan Plateau
Andrew T. Smith
and J. Marc Foggin
(Department of Biology, Box 871501,
Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ85287-1501)
¡ï1.
Introduction¡ï2
Pikas as a Keystone Species¡ï3
Control of Pikas¡ï4
Discussion
Biodiversity is the totality of
genes, species, and ecosystems in a region, and is the product of hundreds of
millions of years of evolutionary history (WRI, IUGN and UNEP 1992). Biodiversity
provides humankind with a variety of direct and indirect values which, combined,
are essential for the well-being of the human species (Costanza et al. 1997,
Primack 1998). The Biodiversity Working Group of the China Council for international
Cooperation in Environment and Development (CCICED) has calculated that the
total value of biodiversity for China equates to approximately $255 - 410 billion
per year (CCICED1996), and these figures - in the light of recent work (c.f
Costanza et al. 1997) - are certainly underestimates.
China has recognized the importance of biodiversity conservation in many fundamental
ways. China was the fourth country to ratify the Convention on Biological Diversity
and actively participates in CITES. China has aggressively adopted a proactive
Agenda 21 (becoming the first developing country to do so), and has produced
a China Action Plan for Biodiversity Conservation and a China Country Study
for Biodiversity. The CCICED is a model organization for the integration of
wide-ranging ideas into a policy framework for sustainable utilization of biological
resources throughout China. Environmental policy in China is as advanced as
in any country on earth. The primary problem faced by China, as well as all
nations, is how to successfully implement environmental policy in a world that
is inherently complex.
The Qinghai-Tibet (Tibetan) Plateau occupies 2. 5 million square kilometers,
approximately 25% of the area of the PRC. It has been estimated that 70% of
the Plateau is rangeland, and Tibetan pastoralism is the primary sustainable
use of this rangeland (Ekvall 1968, Miller and Craig 1997). Although the Plateau
is not as biologically rich as some other areas in China, it does contain a
distinctive flora and fauna (MacKinnon et al. 1996, Schaller 1998). Most ungulate
species found on the Plateau are listed as Category I or Category II Nationally
Protected Fauna in China (MacKinnon et al. 1996). At the present it is impossible
to know the full extent of endangered species on the Plateau, because the list
of Nationally Protected Fauna in China is heavily biased toward charismatic
species and does not contain less prominent fauna even when they have been internationally
recognized as threatened (Baillie and Groombridge 1996).
Biodiversity conservation on an area as vast as the Tibetan Plateau is a complex
endeavor. Here, we concentrate on one feature of this ecosystem and show its
relevance to the overall of biodiversity and ecosystem health on the Plateau.
We present the Plateau Pika (Ochotona curzoniae) as a Keystone Species
in the Tibetan Plateau ecosystem. In spite of the critical ecological role played
by the Plateau Pika in this ecosystem, this species has been the target of widespread
poisoning campaigns designed to eliminate it. We argue that an attempt to selectively
eliminate the Plateau Pika is detrimental to the preservation of native biodiversity
and the normal functioning of the Tibetan Plateau ecosystem. If China is to
implement successfully its forward policy of biodiversity conservation on the
Tibetan Plateau, the pika should be considered as a positive element and widespread
poisoning activities to kill pikas should be halted.
2 Pikas as a Keystone Species
A keystone species is one that, if lost, will lead to a cascading effect of reduced biodiversity and interfere with the proper functioning of an ecosystem (Primack 1998). The Plateau Pika is a Keystone Species because it 1 ) makes burrows that are the primary homes to a wide variety of small birds and lizards; 2) creates microhabitat disturbance that results in an increase in plant species diversity; 3) serves as the main prey for most of the small to medium to large predators on the Plateau; 4) contributes positively to ecosystem-level dynamics by recycling soil; and 5) enhances above-ground and below-ground (root) biomass .
2.1 Biodiversity Of Symbiotic
Animals
The Tibetan Plateau is
largely a treeless environment, and the open meadows that constitute the majority
of the plateau ecosystem offer little in the way of protection for nesting animals.
The burrows constructed by the Plateau Pika offer breeding habitat for many
species. Hume's ground jay (Pseudopodoces humilis) and several species
of snowfinch (Montilnngilla spp.) nest mainly in pika burrows (Meyer
de Schaunensee 1984, Ma 1995, Schaller 1998, Smith et al. 1990). These birds
are more abundant in area of pikas (Ma 1995). Similarly, Pere David's snow finches
(Pyrgiauda davidiana) and Isabelline wheatears (Oenanthe isabelfina)
regularly nest in the holes of Daurian pikas (O. daurica), an ecologically
similar species that also occupies portions of the Plateau (Smith et al. 1990).
In addition, native lizards (Phrynocephalus, Eremias) use pika burrows
for cover and as breeding sites. Loss of pikas, and thus the burrows they create,
contributes to a direct loss of these species and a reduction of native biodiversity
on the Tibetan Plateau.
2.2 Increased Plant Species Richness
Evidence for increased plant species richness caused by the burrowing activities
of the Plateau Pika is indirect, because there are insufficient studies on this
phenomenon in the Tibetan Plateau ecosystem. However, a wide variety of studies
on similar species on grasslands in other areas, including Asia, all indicate
that the surface disturbance caused by burrowing animals commonly increases
plant species richness compared to areas without burrowing animals (Ellison
1946, Grant et al. 1980, Grinnell 1923, Huntly and Reichman 1994, Tilman 1983).
On the Mongolian steppe, Dmitriev (1985) and Tsendzhav (1985) found that local
floral diversity is enhanced due to the burrowing of Daurian pikas (some shrub
plants only grow on pika burrows). Certain plants (Euphorbia altaica, Artemesia
spp., and some crucifers) grow only on the burrows of Pallas's pika (O.
pallasi pricei; Kholodova 1975). Thus, it is likely that effects of burrowing
of the Plateau Pika would mirror these other studies and yield a higher plant
species richness than in areas where pikas have been exterminated. Under current
heavily overgrazed conditions on the Plateau, however, it would be difficult
to determine the direct effects of this relationship. It will take long-term
controlled experiments in areas that are not overgrazed to evaluate the full
association between pikas and plant diversity.
2.3 Pikas Serve as Prey for Many
Native Wildlife Species
Most of the predatory animals on the Tibetan Plateau rely heavily on pikas in
their diet (Schaller 1998, Smith et al. 1990). Pikas are not only the most abundant
source of food for predators during the summer, but as pikas do not hibernate,
they become almost the sole source of food during winter. When pikas are exterminated,
this important source of food disappears and the effect is to starve these species
resulting in a loss of local biodiversity. We have driven across vast stretches
of the Plateau without seeing any raptors soaring in the sky - these are the
areas void of pikas due to prior poisoning campaigns. Conversely, the presence
of raptors indicates areas of healthy pika populations.
The ecological niche of the Plateau Pika is similar in many respects to that
of prairie dogs (Cynomys) of North America, and it is possible that the
polecat (Mustela eversmanni), like its counter part in North America
(the black-footed ferret M. nigripes), is tied in some way to the dynamics
of pika populations (Nekipelov 1954, Schaller 1985, Smith et al. 1990). In North
America the control of prairie dogs has resulted in the near extirpation of
the black-footed ferret, ferrets are only being rescued from extinction with
very expensive intervention (Miller et al. 1996). Similarly, other small mammals
such as weasels (Mustela spp.), foxes (Vulpes spp.), and Pallas's
cat (Otocolobus manul) rely heavily on pikas for food (Schaller 1998,
Smith et al. 1990).
Even many larger mammalian predators such as wolves (Canis lupis), snow
leopards (Uncia uncia), and brown bears (Ursus arctos) can prey
on animals as small as the plateau pika (Schaller 1998). Snow leopards largely
specialize on big game and pikas act only as a buffer species (Schaller 1998).
However, pikas comprise over 50% of the diet of wolves in some areas (Schaller1998),
and brown bears appear particularly reliant on pikas for food. One study on
the Chang Tang found almost 60% of the diet of brown bears to be pikas (Schaller
1998). In fact, pikas form such an important part of the diet of brown bears
on the Plateau, that when Przewalski (1883) secondarily defined this form, he
called it U. lagomyiarius or "bear pika-eater." Kozlov (1899)found
25 pikas in the stomach of one bear.
Most of the large predatory birds on the Tibetan Plateau depend upon pikas as
a food source: Steppe eagles (Aquila nipalensis), upland buzzards (Buteo
hemilasius), saker falcons (Falco cherrug), goshawks (Accipiter
gentilis), black kites (Milvus migrans), little owls (Athene noctua),
etc. Schaller (1998) determined that 90% of pellets under the nest of a saker
falcon contained pikas, while all of the pellets beneath the nest of an upland
buzzard contained pika remains. The similar Daurian pika has been shown to comprise
the following percentages of the diet of avian predators in southeast Transbaikalia
steppe eagle, 62%, upland buzzard, 17%, eagle owl (Bubo bubo), 73%, and
saker falcon, 22% (Peshkov 1957, 1967).
2.4 Contributions To Ecosystem
Function
The Plateau Pika may contribute
in many ways to enhanced functioning of the Plateau ecosystem. Like fossorial
animals in other ecosystems, they may act to increase local primary plant productivity,
aid in the formation, aeration and mixing of soil, and enhance infiltration
of water into the soil (Ellison 1946, Grant et al. 1980, Grinnell 1923, Huntly
and Reichman 1994, Tilman 1983). Burrowing mammals, such as pikas, do not increase
levels of erosion rather erosion in most cases is caused by overgrazing of vegetation
by domestic livestock (Ellison 1946. Schaller 1985). Jiang and Xia (1985, 1987)
determined that the foraging of small and moderate populations of Plateau Pikas
is selective and may play an important role in the stabilization of the alpine
meadow vegetational community. Studies on the similar Daurian pika have shown
that their digging activity loosens and improves the soil, and the accumulation
of their excrement and leftover stores in the burrow system yields high levels
of organic materials. Soil temperatures and humidity are higher, and concentrations
of nitrogen, calcium, and phosphorus are greater near burrow systems then in
nearby areas without pika burrows (Tsendzhav 1985). The result of these interactions
is a greater biomass of roots taller plants, and increased density of plant
cover near the burrow system then elsewhere, the overall biomass of plants when
growing over the burrow system of Daurian pikas is almost five times greater
than in the surrounding steppe (Tsendzhav 1985). In addition, in spring the
phenology of plants growing over burrow systems is 10 to 15 days advanced over
plants growing on areas of nearby steppe without pikas. Similar studies have
been recently been conducted on another fossorial animal found on the Tibetan
Plateau and which is also subject to control, the zokor (Myospalax baileyi).
The above ground biomass of plants on zokor mounds which emerged on an area
of primary vegetation was significantly higher than on an area of secondary
vegetation. The soil of fresh and old mounds was higher in available nitrogen
and phosphorus content than randomly collected samples. Above ground biomass
surrounding mounds was significantly higher than control areas (Wang et al.
1993).
2.5 Summary
The Plateau Pika fulfills all of the component parts of the definition of a
Keystone Species: 1) its presence adds ecological niches in the environment
which are used by native species; 2) it serves as an important source of food
to a wide variety of predators - many of which can not survive without the pika;
and 3) it contributes in a meaningful way to many aspects of ecosystem function.
Of this list, the first two constitute direct benefits to biodiversity on the
Tibetan Plateau. The third function concerning ecosystem services is indirect,
and currently there are no long-term studies as to how the poisoning of pikas
(and zokors) may change ecosystem functioning on the Plateau. There is a pressing
need for controlled investigations and analyses of this problem.
3 Control of Pikas
3.1 Background
In spite of these contributions of the Plateau Pika to the Tibetan Plateau ecosystem,
this species has been targeted for control (Fan et al. 1986, Liu et al. 1980,
Ma 1995, Schaller 1985, Shen and Chen 1984, Smith et al. 1990, Zhong et al.
1985). Here "control" is defined as the deliberate poisoning of a
native species with the intent to reduce its density or eliminate it altogether
from a geographic area. The Plateau Pika is the focus of this paper, but other
species of pika (O. daurica, O. pallasi) and the zokor (Myospalax
spp.) are also targets of control. Within China these activities are normally
termed "rodent control" - but as pikas are lagomorphs and not rodents,
this is a misnomer (a better term would be small-mammal control, in this paper
we simply use the term control).
Plateau Pikas have been targeted
for control primarily because they putatively cause negative effects on rangeland
habitat and are competitors for forage that could otherwise be utilized by livestock.
In addition, the many burrows constructed by pikas are hazards to individuals
who ride horses across the grasslands. These reasons are identical to those
given in the United States for control of prairie dogs (Cynomys ) - a
species that is ecologically equivalent to the Plateau Pika (Schaller 1985).
A final reason for pika control efforts is more insidious: the practice continues
because of vested interests by agencies responsible for control. In China (like
in the United States and elsewhere), agencies and research institutions with
a primary responsibility for control issues can take on a life of their own
- and for them to admit that some of their practices are outdated or unnecessary
would put some employees out of work.
3.2 Extent of Control
Placing the blame for degraded rangelands on the Plateau on pikas is an old
pursuit. Ekvall (1964) who worked in the Amdo region during the 1930s commented
that pastoralists attributed "black sands" areas to pikas (see below).
This observation pre-dates rangeland degradation that has occurred in the past
three decades. In Qinghai currently it has been estimated that "rodent"
(viz. pika or zokor) infested areas total 44,720 km2 (Jing et al. 1986). Control
is recommended when the populations of these small mammal reach high densities
(thus the term "infested").
Control of small mammal populations on the Plateau began in 1958 with tests
on the Plateau Pika. Large-scale control efforts were initiated in 1962 and
reached a peak between 1963 and 1965 (13 million ha, Smith et al. 1990) and
continues on a reduced scale. Between 1986 and 1994 alone, nearly 7.5 million
ha of grassland were controlled (poisoned) to eradicate small mammals and, to
a lesser degree, insects (QAHB 1996). In 1997 we observed television programs
in Beijing extolling the virtues of rodent control measures on the Plateau.
The continued emphasis on control programs indicates that extremely large tracts
of pastureland on the Plateau have been poisoned to kill pikas (Ma 1995, Schaller
1985, 1998, Smith et al. 1990).
An unfortunate consequence of these campaigns to kill Plateau (and Daurian and
Pallas's) pikas is that other pika species may inadvertently be targeted and
killed. The IUCN/SSC Lagomorph Specialist Group recognizes several species and
subspecies of pika in China (most inhabiting the high plateau country) as being
threatened (Baillie and Groombridge 1996, Chapman and Flux 1991; see also Ma
1995). Most pikas look alike, thus there is opportunity for some of these threatened
forms to be inadvertently poisoned - with direct negative ramifications of efforts
to preserve native biodiversity on the plateau.
In the early years, when extensive control occurred, the main chemicals were
Compound 1080 and Fussol, applied from hand spreaders, tractors, and often broadcast
from airplanes. Application of Fussol was discontinued because of expense and
environmental contamination from poisonous secondary derivatives. Use of Compound
1080 continued until 1978 when it was determined that it also killed carnivores
that ate pikas (Smith et al.1990). Because of the importance given to pest control
in China, research on poisons has been well-funded, and almost all rodenticides
have been tried. Gophacide and Zinophos then became the primary control agents.
A major emphasis is now the use of anti-coagulants to avoid secondary by-products
and damage to the environment. Anti-coagulants, however, are expensive and must
be distributed in large quantity over several applications to be effective (Smith
et al. 1990).
3.3 Relationship of Pikas and Livestock
Plateau Pikas are controlled because they putatively compete with livestock
for forage and are found at very high densities (which may reach 300/ha; Liu
et al. 1980, Shen and Chen 1984. Smith et al. 1990). This condition normally
occurs at the end of summer when the pikas normally high rate of reproduction
has yielded its greatest population density and the meadow vegetation has begun
to dry up.
There is also an apparent relationship between grazing of domestic animals and
pika population density. When the combined grazing of yaks, sheep and horses
lower the degree of cover and the height of vegetation, Plateau Pikas may be
found at greater densities than on natural meadows (Shi 1983). Similarly, Daurian
Pikas are more likely to contribute to the deterioration of rangelands that
are already overgrazed (Zhong et al.1985). The zokor, another species that is
often held responsible for soil and vegetation disturbances in alpine plant
communities on the Plateau, reportedly has a higher survival rate in heavily
grazed sites (Cincotta et al. 1992). Apparently under conditions initiated by
pikas and other small mammals on the Plateau are in a position to do greater
harm to the grassland environment. The question can be raised as to whether
the high densities of pikas (and zokors) are causal of rangeland degradation,
or merely symptomatic of overgrazing by livestock (see also Cincotta et al.
1992). Shi (1983) concluded that the most effective way to control damage by
pikas would be to improve the condition of the range, which would presumably
mean to reduce the intensity of grazing by domestic livestock.
Competition between Plateau Pikas and livestock is dependent on the density
of pikas and the quality of the rangeland. The foraging of pikas at low and
moderate densities (such as found in normal situations) is selective and overtaps
little with the diet of domestic grazing animals, thus the pikas may play an
important role in the stabilization of the alpine meadow vegetation community,
(Jingo and Xia 1985, 1987). However, the diet of pikas may overlap extensively
with livestock when pika density is extremely high (such as found in situations
where rangelands are already heavily grazed, see above, Jiang and Xia 1985,
1987). The situation is compiicated further in that overgrazing incr6ases the
proportion of ptants unpalatable or poisonous to livestock (Lang et al. 1997),
and pikas tend to eat those plants that livestock do not eat (Stellaria,
Ligularia, Schaller 1985, 1998). Schaller (1985, 1998) further determined
that by eating herbs, pikas may slow the spread of plants not palatable to livestock,
and thus improve conditions of grasses and sedges preferred by livestock. Thus,
pikas do not appear to compete with livestock for forage on well-managed ranges,
and on degraded ranges where pika densities are high and competition might exist,
pikas still provide a beneficial service to the livestock.
The alpine meadows of the Tibetan Plateau contain areas of small depressions
with steep edges and larger areas primarily devoid of vegetation, termed locally
as "black sands". Areas of extensive black sands lack the deep sod
base that is so typical of the alpine meadows, although on many of these areas
a luxurious monoculture of mint (Elscholtzia sp.) grows late in the summer
season. Plateau Pikas are thought to contribute to the origin of these areas,
which are indicative of degraded rangeland. As pikas have been observed frequently
to utilize the edges of these depressions as cover and to eat plant roots there,
it has been suggested that pikas may expand the extent of black sand areas (Schaller
1998). As mentioned earlier, Ekvall (1964) commented that pikas were responsible
for the creation of black sand areas as early as the 1930s.
One of us (Smith) has worked extensively with fully marked populations of the
Plateau Pika, and one analysis directly addressed the issue of habitat utilization
by pikas on the alpine meadow. Working on a 2 ha study area containing 26 pika
families, we identified three distinct habitat types: 1) meadow dominated by
sedges (Carex spp.; Kobresia spp.), 2) small depressions (1 - 5 m across)
in the sedge meadow that contained a variety of grasses and sedges, and 3) black
sands. Although meadow accounted for an average of 84% of the area, 47.4% of
our 800 grid cells contained black sand habitat. Additionally, we measured habitat
edges, slope of the habitat, burrows and "duck holes" (burrows that
did not link to an underground burrow system). We examined the relationship
of dispersal movements of marked individuals to determine if they favored any
of these components of the habitat. Although 192 correlational tests were run
with both parametric and non-parametric procedures, we found that none of the
family ranges of dispersing and philopatric pikas exhibited significant differences
in any of the habitat characteristics (Dobson and Smith, in press). Thus, although
casual observations have suggested that pikas prefer edges offered by depressions
and black sands, our work does not confirm this conclusion; rather, it shows
that pikas tend to utilize the alpine meadow randomly.
There are other hypotheses as to the origin of black sand areas. One hypothesis
is that trails cut on hillsides by livestock cause the compaction of soil and
formation of erosion terraces - processes that may initiate the decline of a
meadow and lead to a black sands situation (Ma et al. 1997, Schaller 1998).
Another hypothesis is that anthropogenic activities, such as the cutting of
sod by pastoralists to make walls and fireplaces, create clearings that expand
into black sands. Finally, a demonstrable warming trend has been detected on
the Plateau (Miehe 1988, 1996), and the resulting desiccation may be changing
the meadow into a semiarid alpine steppe across much of the Tibetan Plateau.
These changes in climate may be upsetting the natural balance of the vegetation
community leading to formation of black sands.
4 Discussion
4.1 Potential Outcomes of a Pika
Control Program
We began this paper by depicting China's progressive policies toward the promotion
of biodiversity and conservation. We now find that there are other governmental
policies in China that promote the control of an ecological keystone species
such as the Plateau Pika, which operate in opposition to China's biodiversity
policies. Contravening policies are common in all countries, but they establish
a situation that requires a close look at the costs and benefits of each policy.
In the case of the Plateau Pika, let us look at the potential outcomes of a
pika control program and then weigh each of these against the goal of biodiversity
and ecosystem conservation.
Potential Outcome
#1: All pikas can be eliminated by control programs, and this can
be done without
affecting other components of the Tibetan Plateau ecosystem and its biodiversity
1£© Any attempt to eliminate (exterminate) all pikas would be very costly, and
may be ecologically impossible.
2£© Even if all pikas were to be eliminated, the analysis presented here clearly
shows that pikas are a Keystone Species - their presence is necessary for the
survival of many different classes of animals and plants, and they perform essential
ecosystem services. Thus, Potential Outcome #1 is an impossible one - the pikas
cannot be eliminated without seriously comprising the biodiversity and health
of the Tibetan Plateau.
Potential Outcome #2: All pikas can be eliminated and the result
will be a stimulation of productivity of livestock.
1£© Any attempt to eliminate (exterminate) all pikas would be very costly, and
may be ecologically impossible.
2£© This outcome is based on the premise upon which most control programs are
based that controlling the Plateau Pika will yield positive benefits to the
economically important utilization of the Tibetan grassland ecosystem. Massive
control has taken place over the past three decades, and many broad regions
of the Tibetan Plateau have been cleansed of pikas. In spite of the extent of
control, however, productivity and health of livestock on the Plateau has been
declining. Livestock weight has declined. Animals are weak when entering the
critical winter season and massive starvation of herds is becoming a too frequent
event (viz. the situation in Yushu and other ounties in southern Qinghai recently).
Clearly, the control policy has not improved the situation on the grasslands
appreciably.
Potential Outcome #3: Pikas are eliminated only temporarily
or in restricted geographical areas.
The cost of control is high, thus the cost of partial control, with the pikas
and other controlled animals in a position to bounce back in population within
a short time, is not cost-effective. Short-term control may be warranted in
conjunction with other activities to restore the health of degraded pasture
(such as removal of livestock), but these situations must be evaluated carefully
to assure that they do not jeopardize the role of pikas as a Keystone Species
in the ecosystem. In a general sense, if control is too pervasive, then biodiversity
conservation and ecosystem function are jeopardized, but if control is too restricted
(temporally or spatially), it is bound to be ineffective. Thus, it appears that
short-term control is unsustainable and not cost effective.
Potential Outcome #4: Control fails to eliminate pikas.
The cost implications of failure are obvious. In this outcome, control is a
lose-lose situation - cost is high and there are no potential benefits of control.
That expensive control measures that accomplish little should not be undertaken
is obvious. Yet, we have recent examples of just such cases. We were recently
informed (1997) by individuals in an international aid agency in Beijing that
they were promoting a control program directed at Plateau Pikas in spite of
the fact that they knew such an activity was counter-productive to long-term
sustainability in the area in which they were working. Their rationale for funding
the control program was to demonstrate that they were actually spending money
in China - regardless of the outcome. Ultimately this program collapsed because
it failed to control pikas and was too expensive. It is unfortunate that the
resources spent on this misguided venture were not expended for programs consistent
with a long-term goal - a sustainable program for utilization of the rangelands.
4.2 Comprehensive Rangeland Management
In this paper we have addressed a single component of the complex of factors
governing the biodiversity and sustainable development of the alpine grasslands
of the Tibetan Plateau. We wish to stress that these rangeland resources must
be viewed comprehensively. Just as we have documented that campaigns to poison
Keystone Species such as pikas and other small mammals in this ecosystem is
short-sighted, when viewed from the perspective of biodiversity and ecosystem
conservation, so should we be skeptical of other apparent quick fixes to this
ecosystem (such as planting grasses, fencing, winter housing, etc.). Some of
these approaches may be justified in a restricted geographical area, but the
entire alpine grassland ecosystem on the Tibetan Plateau is at risk (Lang et
al. 1997, Miller 1995, Schaller 1998). What are needed are studies to evaluate
the long-term sustainability of the ecosystem - studies that begin with the
health of the alpine meadow which is the cornerstone for all biodiversity and
pastoralist activity. Here we have shown that the Plateau pika is one key element
in this system and have argued that managing pika populations should be viewed
as part of the solution, not part of the problem, facing a comprehensive solution
for the restoration of Tibet's rangelands.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank IUCN - The World Conservation Union, the Biodiversity
Working Group of the China Council for International Cooperation in Environment
and Development, and the Center for Asian Studies at Arizona State University
for their generous support of this endeavor. Harriet Smith kindly read and commented
on the manuscript.
Bibliography
Baillie, J., and B. Groombridge (eds). 1996. 1996 IUCN Red List of Threatened
Animals. IUCN. Gland, Switzerland.
CCICED. 1996. Proceedings of the fourth meeting of the China Council for International
Cooperation on Environment and Development. Beijing.
Chapman, J. A., and J. E. C. Flux (eds). 1990. Rabbits, hares, and pikas:
Status survey and conservation action plan. IUCN. Gland, Switzerland.
Cincotta, R., Y. Zhang, and X. Zhou. 1992. Transhumant alpine pastoralism in
northeastern Qinghai Province: An evaluation of livestock population response
during China's agrarian reform. Nomadic Peoples 30:3-25.
Costanza, R., R. d'Arge, R. deGroot, S. Farber, M. Grasso, B. Hannon, K. Limburg,
S. Naeem, R.V. O'Neill, J. Paruelo, R.G. Raskin, P. Sutton, and M. van den Belt.
1997. The value of the world's ecosystem services and natural capital. Nature
387: 253-260 .
Dmitney, P. P. 1985. The relationship between some shrubs of the Mongolian steppes
and colonies of mammals. Zh. Obshch Biol. 46: 661-669.
Dobson, F. S., and A. T. Smith. In Press. Social and ecological influences on
dispersal and philopatry in the plateau pika (Ochotona curzoniae).
Behavioral Ecology.
Ekvall, R. B. 1968. Fields on the Hoof: Nexus of Tibetan Nomadic Pastoralism.
Waveland Press. Prospect Heights, Illinois.
Ellison, L. 1946. The pocket gopher in relation to soil erosion on mountain
ranges. Ecology 27: 101 -114.
Fan, N., Z. Jing, Q. Wang, and W. Zhou. 1 986. Studies on bromadiolone against
the pika and the zokor. Acta Theriologica Sinica 621 1 -21 7.
Grant, W., N. French, and L. FoISe. 1980. Effects of pocket gopher mounds on
plant production in shortgrass prairie ecosystems. Southwestern Naturalist
25: 215-224.
Grinnell, J. 1923. The burrowing rodents of California as agents in soil formation.
Journal of Mammalogy 4: 137-149.
Huntly, N., and O. J. Reichman. 1994. Effect of Subterranean mammalian herbivores
on
vegetation. Journal of Mammalogy 75: 852-859
Jiang, Z., and W. Xia. 1985. Utilization of food resources by plateau pikas.
Acta Thenologica Sinica 5: 251 -262 .
Jiang, Z., and W. Xia. 1987. The niches of yaks, Tibetan Sheep and plateau pikas
in the alpine meadow ecosystem. Acta Biologica Plateau Sinica 6: 115-146.
Jing, S., et al. 1986. The Situation of Qinghai Province. Qinghai People's
Publishing House. Xining.
Kholodova, M. V. 1975. Studies of the connections between the Mongolian pika
(Ochotona pricei Thomas) and other vertebrates of Tuva's stony mountain
steppe. Unpublished report. Dept. of Vertebrate Zoology, Moscow State University,
Moscow.
Koslov, P. K. 1899. Proceedings of the Expedition of the Imperial Russian Geographical
Society in Central Asia 1893-1896 under the direction of Roborovski, volume
2.
Lang, B-N., J-S. Huang, and HY. Wang. 1997. Report on the pasture and livestock
survey in Hainan IFAD Project Area. IFAD.
Liu, J., Y. Zhang, and G. Xin. 1980. Relationship between numbers and degree
of harmfulness of the plateau pika. Acta Zoologica Sinica 26: 378-385.
Ma, M. 1995. Suggestions for the protection of some pikas. China Nature
2:26.
Ma, Y., B. Lang, and Q . Li. 1997. Improve yak productivity through resuming
"black soil type" deteriorated grassland, pp. 291-294. In: R. Yang,
X. Han, and X. Luo, (eds.). Yak Production in Central Asian Highlands.
Qinghai People's Publishing House, Xining.
MacKinnon, J., M. Sha, C. Cheung, G. Carey, Z. Xiang, and D. MelVille. 1996.
A Biodiversity Review of China. World Wide Fund for Nature International.
Hong Kong.
Miehe. G. 1988. Geoecological reconnaissance in the alpine belt of southern
Tibet. GeoJournal 17: 635.-648.
Miehe, G. 1996. On the connection of vegetation dynamics with climatic changes
in High Asia. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology Palaeoecolgy 120: 5-24.
Miller, B., R. P. Reading, and S. Forrest. 1996. Prairie Night: Black-footed
Ferret and the Recovery of Endangered Species. Smithsonian Institution Press.
Washington, D. C.
Miller, D. J. 1995. Herds on the move: Winds of change among pastoralists
in the Himalayas and on the Tibetan plateau. International Centre for integrated
Mountain Development. Kathmandu, Nepal.
Miller, D. J., and S. R. Craig (eds). 1997. Rangelands and Pastoral Development
in the Hindu Kush-Himalayas. International Centre for integrated Mountain
Development. Kathmandu, Nepal.
Meyer de Schauensee, R. 1984. The Birds of China. Smithsonian Institution
Press. Washington DC.
Nekipelov, N. V. 1954. Changes in numbers of the Daurian pika in southwest Transbaikalia.
Izv. Irkutsk. Nauchno-issled. Protivochumnpeo. Ins. Sib. Dal'nego Vost. 12:
171 -180.
Peshikov, B. I. 1957. Data on numbers and diet of foathered predators of southeast
Transbaikalia. Izv. Irkutsk. Nauchno-Issted. Protivochumnogo. Ins. Sib. Dal'nego
Vost. 16: 143-153.
PeShikov, B. I. 1967. On the biology of the upland buzzard. Isv. Irkutsk. Nauchno-Issled.
Protivochumnogo. Ins. SIb. Dat'nego Vost. 27: 167-174.
Prezewalski, N. M. 1883. From Zaisan Lake through the Kham region of Tibet
and the head of the Yellow River, second edition (1948). Moscow.
Primack, R. B. 1998. Essentials of Conservation Biology, Second edition.
Sinauer. Sunderland, Massachusetts.
QAHB. 1996. Summary of experiences, goal clarification and the promotion of
animal husbandry. Provincial animal husbandry development and its future tasks.
Qinghai Animal Husbandry Bureau. Xining.
Schaller, G. B. 1985. Wildlife in the middle kingdom. Defenders 60:10-15.
Schaller, G. B. 1998. Wildlife Of the Tibetan Steppe. University of Chicago
Press. Chicago.
Shen, S., and Y. Chen. 1984. Preliminary research on ecology of the plateau
pika at the Dawu area, Guoluo, Qinghai Province. Acta Theriologica Sinica
4: 107-115.
Shi, Y. 1983. On the inftuence of rangeland vegetation to the density of plateau
pikas (Ochotona curzoniae). Acta Theriologica Sinica 3: 181-187.
Smith, A. T., A. N. Formozov, R. S. Hoffmann, Zheng Changlin and M. A. Erbajeva.
1990. The pikas. pp. 14-60. In: J. A. Chapman and J. E. C. Flux (eds.) Rabbits,
hares, and pikas: Status survey and conservation action plan. IUCN. Gland,
Switzerland.
Tilman, D. 1983. Plant succession and gopher disturbance along an experimental
gradient. Oecologia 60: 285-292.
Tsendzhay, D. 1985. The role of the Daurian pika (Ochotona daurica Pallas,
1776) in the
biogeocenosis of Eastern Khangai. Abstract of Candidate degree thesis. UIan-Bator,
Mongolia.
Wang, Q., J. Bian, and Y. Shi. 1993. Influence of plateau zokor mounds on the
vegetation and soil nutrients in an alpine meadow, Acta Theriologica Sinica
13: 31-37.
WRI, IUCN, and UNEP. 1992. Global Biodiversity Strategy. World Resources
Institute. Washington, DC. .
Zhong, H., Q. Zhou, and C. Sun. 1985. The basic characteristics of the rodent
pests on the pasture in Inner Mongolia and the ecological strategies of controlling.
Acta Theriologica Sinica 5: 241-249.